Part II of Dr. Brian Sommer’s deep dive into what golfer’s truly want from instruction
By Brian Sommer, PhD
Consider a woman who wants to improve enough to join her friends in a weekly ladies’ league. It would be easy to interpret this as a straightforward request for golf instruction. She wants to play better. We should examine her swing, identify its weaknesses, and help her achieve the proficiency required to participate.
Perhaps.
But what does she actually want?
Does she enjoy competition? Does she want to spend Thursday mornings with her friends? Is she interested in becoming a more accomplished golfer? Does she worry about slowing everyone down? Has someone told her she isn’t good enough? Has she decided that participation requires a standard of performance she hasn’t yet reached?
Or does she simply want to play golf?
These are questions worth exploring, not because I possess some privileged understanding of her motives, but because I don’t. And that distinction is important. I have met coaches who could tell you, within ninety seconds of meeting a golfer, what the golfer “really” wanted. It is a remarkable talent, and like most such talents it works by the simple device of choosing the answer in advance and then interpreting all evidence in its favor. Any prophet can fill a temple, provided the prophecy is vague enough.
The modern appetite for psychological interpretation can become every bit as intrusive as the appetite for mechanical correction. We are perfectly capable of replacing an instructor who diagnoses a faulty takeaway with a coach who diagnoses a fear of failure, a limiting belief, or an unresolved relationship with achievement.
The terminology changes. The presumption of authority remains.
I have no interest in telling a golfer what she really wants. I am interested in discovering it with her, if there is something to be discovered.
Perhaps she explains that she would love to play with her friends but doesn’t think she’s good enough. We might become
curious about what good enough means. Has the league established a minimum standard? Have her friends expressed concern? Has she played with them before?
Or is the requirement entirely her own?
It is possible that a brief conversation reveals she can join them next week.
No swing change. No mental performance intervention. No elaborate exercise designed to manufacture confidence. She simply discovers that the obstacle she believed stood between her and an enjoyable Thursday morning may not exist.
Which would raise the interesting question of who installed it. Obstacles of this kind are rarely self-generating. Somebody, somewhere, is usually in the business of installing them and that somebody does not work for free.
Of course, the conversation could go differently. She might want to compete seriously. She might enjoy the challenge of developing particular shots. She might be eager to explore how she moves the club and what she can do with it.
Wonderful.
Then we have something else to explore.
The Returning Golfer
Now consider the golfer who wants to return to the game after twenty years away. Perhaps he played constantly as a child. He remembers summer afternoons when the days seemed endless, when he carried a half-set of clubs, played until the light disappeared, and thought very little about what his hands, shoulders, or hips were doing.
He remembers trying ridiculous shots because they looked interesting. He remembers hitting balls over trees, beneath branches, around corners, and occasionally into places from which no sensible recovery was possible.
He remembers playing.
Then life intervened. Education, career, marriage, children, responsibilities. Golf became something he used to do.
Now he wants to return. What does he want from coaching?
Perhaps he wants to recover some of the skill he once possessed. Perhaps he wants to see whether he can still strike the ball as he remembers. Perhaps he’s curious about what his older body can do.
But perhaps what he misses most is the freedom. The enjoyment of hitting a golf ball without the burden of evaluating every movement. The ease with which he once experimented. The simple pleasure of being outside with a club
in his hands and somewhere interesting to send the ball.
There is a temptation to interpret his return as a technical rehabilitation project. His body has changed, his swing has changed, and the modern game has accumulated an impressive inventory of equipment and instruction designed to address both. It is a well-stocked pharmacy, and it is always ready with a prescription.
But what if his principal interest is not recovering the swing he had at fifteen? What if he wants to recover something about the experience of being fifteen?
Not the innocence of childhood, which adults tend to romanticize rather extravagantly, but the willingness to play without requiring every movement to justify itself. The boy was probably not a better golfer than the man. He was, however, unacquainted with the idea that a golf swing requires continuous professional supervision, an idea that had not yet been marketed to him. The boy did not necessarily possess a better golf swing. He may have possessed a different relationship with the game. And perhaps that relationship is worth exploring.
The Competitor
Then there’s the golfer who wants to play in the Saturday
money game. He may already be a fine player. He can hit the shots, understands, the course, and knows how to compete. But the Saturday game has acquired a significance beyond the few dollars changing hands.
Perhaps he wants to test himself against good players. Perhaps he enjoys the competition, the banter, the friendships, and the peculiar satisfaction of making a putt when everyone is watching.
Perhaps he has decided he isn’t ready. What would ready mean? Does he need to improve his ball striking? Does he want to explore particular shots? Or has he constructed an imaginary standard of competence that the other players may not recognize? Again, we don’t know. The beauty of not knowing is that it obliges us to ask. And the question becomes more interesting when the golfer wants to compete in the club championship.
Here the ambition may be entirely different. He may want to win. Not merely participate, not rediscover the innocent pleasures of childhood, but win.
I see nothing objectionable about that.
Competitive ambition is not a psychological defect requiring moderation. Nor is it evidence that the golfer has lost sight of
what makes the game enjoyable. Some people love competition, love the risk, love the small honest drama of a putt that matters.
But even here, there is something worth exploring. What does winning mean to this golfer? What does he enjoy about competing? What does he notice when the stakes become meaningful? What possibilities does he see in his game, and what would he like to explore?
The answers might lead us toward ball striking, putting, shot selection, or the experience of playing under pressure. They might also lead somewhere unexpected. The point is not to talk the golfer out of wanting to win. It is to understand the person who wants to win.
The Companions
And there are golfers whose interests are not primarily competitive at all. Consider a husband and wife who want to spend more time together on the course.
Perhaps one has played for decades while the other is relatively new to the game. Perhaps both played years ago and are returning together. Perhaps they want something they can enjoy as they grow older.
Their desire may involve companionship, shared experience,
and the pleasure of spending several uninterrupted hours together. Few activities offer what golf offers here: four hours of conversation, walking, scenery, and the repeated low comedy of a small ball refusing to cooperate.
Yet it would be easy to approach the less experienced player as a collection of technical deficiencies. Correct the grip. Improve the takeaway. Establish the proper sequence. Build a repeatable motion. Before long, an afternoon that was supposed to bring two people together has become a remedial exercise, one partner standing in judgment over the other’s swing, which is not what most marriages were in need of.
What if the more interesting question is how they want to experience golf together?
Perhaps they want to play eighteen holes. Perhaps nine is enough. Perhaps one enjoys competition while the other enjoys the walk. Perhaps they want to learn different shots, or perhaps they simply want to become comfortable enough to enjoy the course without feeling that every shot is an examination.
Their interests may change as they play.
The Child
And what about parents and children? A father wants to play golf with his daughter. A mother wants to share the game with
her son. A family wants an activity that can accompany them through the years.
What are they hoping to experience?
Maybe the parent wants to introduce a child to something that has brought a lifetime of enjoyment. Maybe the child is curious about hitting a ball as far as possible. Maybe they want to compete with one another, invent games, explore the course, or simply spend time together.
I find it difficult to imagine a more unfortunate outcome than turning that experience into an endless sequence of corrections. The child hits a shot, watches the ball fly, and laughs. The adult sees an early extension pattern. One of them is playing golf. The other may be missing something.
This is not an argument against helping children learn. It is a question about what we’re helping them learn, and whose interests are guiding the experience. A child may become fascinated by the mechanics of the golf swing. Wonderful. Another may want to see whether a ball can be made to curve around a tree. Wonderful again.
The experience belongs to them, too.
These golfers have different ambitions. Some want to compete, some want to reconnect, some want to discover, and some
simply want to enjoy the game with people they love.
None is more legitimate than another. And none can be understood fully by examining the golf swing alone.